table of content table of content
One week after the Judgment in the FromBIO case, a second court rules on the advertising contracts of Kim Soo-hyun. On November 20, a South Korean court ruled partially in favor of Cuckoo, the home appliance brand for which he had served as a spokesperson for more than 10 years. But here again, the reality of the ruling is more nuanced than some Korean media headlines suggest (which love to portray him as solely responsible for everything he’s currently going through): the actor isn’t held personally liable; it’s his agency that will have to pay.

What the Judgment Says
The 25th Civil Division of the Seoul Central District Court was reviewing the complaint filed by three companies in the group: Cuckoo Electronics, Cuckoo Homesys, and its Malaysian subsidiary, Cuckoo International Berhad. Together, they were seeking more than 2 billion won from the actor and his agency, Gold Medalist.
The court ruled only partially in their favor. Only the agency was ordered to pay approximately 875 million won: just over 260 million to Cuckoo Electronics and nearly 615 million to Cuckoo Homesys, plus late payment interest. The claims against Kim Soo-hyun in his personal capacity, however, were dismissed.
The detailed reasoning behind the judgment has not yet been made public. The court reportedly found, among other things, a breach of the image rights clause in the advertising contract. It remains to be seen whether the amount represents a refund of the fee, as in the FromBIO case, or damages.
10 years as a brand ambassador, then the breakup
Kim Soo-hyun had been the face of Cuckoo for more than a decade. In early 2025, after allegations surfaced that he had dated Kim Sae-ron while she was a minor, the brand withdrew its advertisements and then filed a lawsuit.
The actor has always denied these allegations. The investigation has since taken a new turn, with Kim Se-ui—who is currently being prosecuted for spreading false information—being implicated, and the case being referred to the district attorney’s office from the case file of Kim Sae-ron's mother and her attorney. A verdict is expected around December 21–22, following several weeks of hearings involving numerous witnesses.
A scenario similar to the FromBIO case
This ruling is similar to the one handed down on November 13 in the dispute with FromBIO, a dietary supplement brand. The Suwon court had ordered the payment of approximately 1.16 billion won. The actor’s representatives had emphasized that he had not been found at fault, that the amount corresponded to a refund stipulated in the contract, and that the court had identified Kim Se-ui as responsible for the damage to his reputation. They immediately filed an appeal.
A precedent that raises questions
Beyond the case of Kim Soo-hyun, these rulings raise a delicate question for the entire industry. If a brand can recoup part of the value of its spokesperson as soon as a controversy erupts, what happens when the accusations at the root of that controversy turn out to be false?
This is the argument that the actor’s camp has been making since the FromBIO ruling. According to his representatives, making a celebrity bear the consequences of false rumors would be tantamount to giving a formidable weapon to «cyber-scammers»—those content creators who thrive on scandals. All it would take, then, would be to make false accusations to cause a star to lose advertising revenue—or even to subject them to outright blackmail.
For their part, advertisers argue that they paid for an image they were unable to use, regardless of the source of the controversy. A balance still needs to be struck between protecting brands and protecting celebrities who are the victims of rumors. The Court of Appeals, which is hearing the FromBIO case, may well provide an initial answer.
Gold Medalist has not yet responded to this new ruling, which was handed down at the trial court level and is subject to appeal.
